Monday, July 14, 2008

WALL-E

Pixar has a pretty strong track record. They don't make many films, but every single one of them has been thoroughly entertaining. They might not all completely rock your world, but with those animators painstakingly scrubbing frame by frame it's pretty hard for complete crap to make it to the final cut. WALL-E completely lives up to its strong pedigree.

After the movie I polled our group to see where WALL-E ranked relative to the other Pixar films. We made it a little technical and did a quick and dirty ladder elimination. Here are the results:

  1. The Incredibles
  2. WALL-E
  3. Ratatouille
  4. A Bug's Life
  5. Monster's Inc.
  6. Finding Nemo
  7. Toy Story
  8. Toy Story 2
  9. Cars

It wasn't the most scientific process, so the list is imperfect. I don't think we ever did all the proper matches in the secondary bracket. But it gives you the gist. WALL-E is one of the best of a very strong list of animated films.

The Incredibles won out in that list, but it's hard to really crown a champion. Fundamentally it's too early to properly place WALL-E (time and another viewing could shift the mix), but there's no doubting that it's really good. Thoroughly enjoyable. Easily recommended to anyone with a pulse.

The premise is kind of similar to that of Idiocracy, except this time there's actually a worthwhile plot. Oh, and robots. Robots make everything better. These aren't your standard mutinizing deathbots, but they're so adorable that I'll forgive their lack of hatred for meatbags.

Most Pixar stories have a strong moral, with varying levels of subtlety. I'm okay with there being a message, but I don’t like being beat over the head with it. It's one of the few things I dislike about Monster's Inc, actually - it gets a little too warm and fuzzy. WALL-E has a message, but I never felt like I was being preached too.

Anyway, WALL-E is a totally charming. Unless you have a heart of coal I'm pretty sure you'll enjoy it.

3 comments:

  1. Wall-E totally looks like the robot from "Short Circuit," minus the cheesy 80's style of course... but i'm sure Pixar made a totally original story otherwise

    ReplyDelete
  2. I just saw this last night at Cinerama. I really enjoyed being "in the moment" with it. I think stories like Cars have a more engaging "larger" plot, but WALL-E shines in a continuous stream of little engaging (and charming) moments.

    ReplyDelete
  3. We saw "WALL-E" last night and loved, loved, loved it. I do take some issue with your rankings though. "Bug's Life" is better than "Toy Story/Toy Story 2"? Really?!

    ReplyDelete